This casserole called for cream of mushroom soup, so I already knew I had a gluten issue to solve. Fortunately, Instagram had recently introduced me to a company that makes a gluten-free mushroom soup mix. Perfect! I ordered it, stuck it in the pantry, and waited for the right recipe to come along.
Well...the right recipe finally came along, and that mushroom soup mix was terrible.
The mix is supposed to be simple—you add milk or water to half a cup of the mix and, poof, you have cream of mushroom soup. Except what I had was something that tasted like soap. Not “hmm, this needs a little something.” Not “maybe it will taste better in the casserole.” Nope. Straight-up soap. It was so bad I couldn't, in good conscience, put it into the casserole.
I went into fix-it mode. I tried adding Worcestershire sauce and a few seasonings, hoping I could rescue it. No such luck. It was still awful.
So I started digging through the pantry to see what else I could use. That's when I spotted a can of Campbell’s French Onion Soup. It was broth-based, which made it seem like a reasonable substitute. I mixed it with a little sour cream and thought, BAM! We have a replacement!
Except...no.
Because it turns out Campbell’s is apparently not my friend when it comes to gluten. So much for my brilliant backup plan.
My BFF still ate the casserole—gluten is a preference issue for her rather than a medical one—and she did her best to scrape off as much of the sauce as possible. She's always a good sport about my kitchen experiments. I even offered to order her a pizza, but she assured me she'd be fine.
As for the casserole itself, I actually think my little pantry substitution worked really well for those of us who can eat gluten. It came together easily and tasted great. I definitely want to make this again sometime, but next time I'll follow the recipe as written and see what I think of the original version.
And there’s your cooking lesson for the day: sometimes you have to pivot.
Recipes are great, but ingredients don't always cooperate. Sometimes something isn't available, sometimes you discover an ingredient doesn't work, and sometimes you realize halfway through that the thing you grabbed from the pantry was a terrible idea. That's when you have to stop, look around, and figure out what you do have that might work.
Google is surprisingly helpful for this. In this case, it pointed me toward using sour cream with some sort of broth, which at least got me moving in the right direction.
So don't be afraid to color outside the recipe lines. Sometimes the best cooking happens when you have to improvise.
- 6 md potatoes, peeled & sliced 1/4" thick
- 2 md sweet onions, sliced 1/4 " thick
- pinch salt & pepper to taste
- 2 can cream of mushroom soup
- 1/2 can cream, divided (soup can)
- 6 pork chops
- a few pinch house seasoning blend or similar (see below)
- dash smoked paprika
- 1 tsp dried sage, crushed/ground
- 1/2 tsp finely minced/ground dried rosemary
- 1/2 tsp dried thyme, crushed/ground
- 4 Tbsp salt
- 1 Tbsp ground black pepper
- 1 Tbsp garlic powder

















